Squeamish Bikini
  • Home
  • Squeamish Features
  • Squeamish Reviews
  • Squeamish News
  • Squeamish Contact
  • About Squeamish

Health Bill's Health

11/10/2011

6 Comments

 
Picture
A few thousand people spent most of Sunday on a bridge in London, blocking traffic and symbolically blocking the Health and Social Care Bill from reaching the House of Lords, where it will be debated on Tuesday and Wednesday. But why – what’s wrong with it?

Well, on a broad level, it looks like a way of introducing market forces into the NHS, when  there remain serious questions as to the effectiveness of ‘market forces’ in regulating and developing health care provision  patients. Beresford : 2005  

I think pretty much everyone can agree that we want to see our healthcare system be as efficient as possible, but opinions differ over how to achieve this. I would say the devil is in the detail – but Cameron and Lansley have set out little in the way of supporting detail for their bill.

Picture
In an interview on ITV on the 4th of October, Cameron said that he believes the proposals “ are right, I think they will improve patient care. Above all, they will be good for patients”. But produced no facts to back up this statement of belief.

Most people in this country are rational beings who are capable of examining a proposal and supporting it or not on the basis of available evidence (now there’s one of MY totally unsubstantiated beliefs) – but the evidence in this case seems to have gone missing.

So if the Prime Minister and his Health Secretary believe the Bill is doing the right thing, what do other people, perhaps ones experienced in this field, think?

Well.

The world’s leading medical journal, the Lancet  argues that the current Bill “spells the end of the NHS”.

The British Medical Association has put out a briefing which takes a measured look at the Bill, and concludes that “the Bill as it currently stands poses an unacceptably high risk to the NHS in England, threatening its ability to operate effectively and equitably. Government health and social care policy, implemented both through and beyond the Bill, will make it harder – not easier – to create the seamless, efficient care that everyone agrees is key to future sustainability.” They call for it to be withdrawn or amended.

The Royal College of Nurses has already had some inputs into changes to the bill, but are looking for more as they have “serious concerns about the Health and Social Care Bill and the reforms that accompany it. We are one of the leading organisations lobbying the Government to change the legislation to reflect the concerns of our members and their patients.”

An open letter to the House of Lords, signed by over 400 experts including 40 Directors of Medicine, was published in The Telegraph arguing that ‘The bill will do irreparable harm to the NHS, to individual patients and to society as a whole’. The same letter continued:

“The Government claims that the reforms have the backing of the health professions. They  do not. Neither do they have the public’s support. The Health and Social Care Bill will  erode the NHS’s ethical and cooperative foundations and will not deliver efficiency, quality,  fairness or choice. We ask the House of Lords to reject passage of the Health and Social  Care Bill.”

(For some reason Cameron took this as a show of support. Which surely says something about the reaction he is used to getting by now)

But these groups are all medical. They probably have some vested interest in wanting to cure people or something. What if that’s getting in the way of what the patients want?

Professor Appleby’s research for The Kings Fund finds that more members of the British public than ever believe that the NHS is doing a good job and are satisfied with their service provision 
 
In contrast, waiting times have risen across the country, and in all areas of healthcare provision, over the last 14 months. This follows the implementation of sub-legislative policy reforms and budgetary cuts  (data published; Department of Health ‘Time Series’: 2011).

Oh. Ok.

But what if the medics and the patients are both wrong?

A review by Millar et al – Liberating the NHS: Orders of Change? –  looks at proposed changes within the NHS: both what they are and how they could be described, and then carries out a literature review of comparable changes elsewhere. Obviously the NHS is unique, but it doesn’t look good. They suggest that the scale of these reforms and their long term effects on the health care service constitute a radical break from previous policies and developments which have not yet been either justified or fully understood in their potential long term effects, and find that the increased focus on price and service competition has no conclusive evidence to suggest that it will necessarily translate into increased quality of care for all patients.

When the group 38 Degrees wanted to put together a legal briefing on the proposed Bill they raised £38, 000 in ONE WEEK and the subsequent briefing raises questions about the statutory provision of care and appropriate overview, accountability and transparency under the reforms being proposed.

These concerns were laid out in a letter to every member of the Lords. You’ll be glad to hear that many of them responded quickly. The winner has to be Lady Richardson, who responded within an hour (from her Blackberry), stating she shared the concerns and would represent them.

If you would like to contact a Lord yourself, 38 degress have a nifty tool you can use to do so.

We’ll be watching on Wednesday.

If you want to write your own letter to a Lord whilst there's still time here are some useful resources-

38Degrees Legal Briefing available here

British Medical Association briefing available here

Royal College of Nurses briefing, available here

UK Uncut press release, available here


Squeamish Louise who informs us, "The vast majority of research was done by Glen Noble, who apparently found it a relaxing alternative to his PhD."

6 Comments
Gareth
10/10/2011 06:10:23 pm

38Degrees also have an email petition they are trying to get as many people as possible to sign, to show the public is overwhelmingly opposed to these changes (which didn't appear in an party manifesto). You can sign it here: http://www.38degrees.org.uk/page/s/nhs-message-to-the-lords

Reply
Squeamish Kate
10/10/2011 06:13:56 pm

Consider it signed and passed on, thanks Gareth

Reply
urine test marijuana link
30/5/2012 09:47:04 pm

It looks like the bill is getting a strong opposition from the people and with so many high profile people linking with it looks hard for it to be passed .

Reply
IPL Epsom link
27/6/2012 06:58:26 pm

I think pretty much everyone can agree that we want to see our healthcare system be as efficient as possible, but opinions differ over how to achieve this.

Reply
What is eye surgery link
22/7/2012 10:15:56 pm

Exactly, what I was after. Cool, I've been looking for this sort of explanation for ever. I've made note of your blog so that I can learn more on the topic.

Reply
visual memory Vancouver link
9/9/2012 03:58:45 pm

I'm happy that I found your blog while searching the internet for ideas and good content. It's very informative and the quality of your posts is excellent.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    Categories

    All
    Books
    Booze
    Cinematic
    Dress Up
    Educating Sue
    Educating Sue
    Friday 5
    Friday 5
    Geekery
    Gender Agender
    Gender Agender
    Glitter And Twisted
    Glitter And Twisted
    History Repeating
    History Repeating
    How To
    Just A Thought
    Just A Thought
    Let's Get Political
    Let's Get Political
    Music
    Nom Nom Nom
    Nostalgia
    Tellybox
    Why You Should Love

    RSS Feed


Squeamish Bikini

About
Contact us
Write for us

Newsletter

Picture
     Copyright © 2013